Serial Numbers - Printable Version
+- iDevGames Forums (http://www.idevgames.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Development Zone (/forum-3.html)
+--- Forum: Game Design (/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Serial Numbers (/thread-5709.html)
Pages: 1 2
Serial Numbers - kodex - Mar 26, 2005 07:52 PM
So im looking for a new way to handle serial numbers, I have the esellerate options but i rather stay away from that, I really dislike mainstream methods.
Right now im using a very simple math algorithm that takes my numbers and applies some formulas to them, if the result == 0 then its valid otherwise its not.
I would really like to move to a more secure method (maybe something using letters+numbers instead of just numbers), anyone have any advise going into this that they may have learned from doing it themselves? Articles? Tips?
Thanks as always guys.
Serial Numbers - DanLab - Mar 27, 2005 12:28 AM
"Right now im using a very simple math algorithm that takes my numbers and applies some formulas to them, if the result == 0 then its valid otherwise its not.
easy to crack or generrate serial
you should look at ambrosia or Freeverse registering system
Serial Numbers - sealfin - Mar 27, 2005 03:39 AM
As far as Ambrosia's serials are concerned, if I remember correctly a blokey at Ambrosia wrote an article on their anti-piracy techniques, and stated that they have some timing data encoded in their serials*, which won't allow you to register a product with that serial after N days â€“ enough time for a legitimate customer, but short enough to make a leaked serial wothless...
(*and apparently the customer's credit card no. in reversable form although this may just be a rumour for discouraging the sharing serials.)
Serial Numbers - DavidJJ - Mar 27, 2005 02:37 PM
I'm wondering why there is no method of making serial numbers tied to a specific MAC address in a computer? I think this is the way that Alias' Maya registers to your machine. I have been told that within hours of posting the new HTML/CSS editor Goodpages, the author was informed that his program had been cracked. Is there no way to tie a program to a machine? Require online registration that actually modifies the application's code to include the users MAC address?
A non-programmers (possibly stupid) question.
Serial Numbers - Zwilnik - Mar 27, 2005 03:39 PM
MAC addresses can be faked too. It also unfortunately ties the game to a single machine for honest users, which isn't generally that great.
Apple use the credit card thing in their Quicktime Pro registrations. Supposedly your credit card info is incorporated into the serial number somehow. Whether it's true or not (Apple claimed it when they first started doing it with QT3) it's a pretty good way of making an honest user worry about sharing his serial code. Unfortunately, once it's past the first user, it doesn't have any effect on the sharers who have no connection with the credit card.
Serial Numbers - kodex - Mar 27, 2005 03:52 PM
From my research,
Pangea Uses peoples credit card infomation encoded into their serial numbers
Ambrosia - Uses a serial that expires 30 days from issue date
Any more insight? I really want to fan the heat of this topic. I think it could get interesting =)
Serial Numbers - maaaaark - Mar 27, 2005 07:09 PM
I use the honor system HAH.
Serial Numbers - Steven - Mar 27, 2005 07:25 PM
Well, given how easy it is to track down serial numbers for many applications, the honor system may not be such a bad idea. I'm sure you can find research to the contrary, however
It would be interesting to know exactly how well it works.
Serial Numbers - kodex - Mar 27, 2005 07:32 PM
I used donate-ware for a while then switched over to limited use share-ware. There was a TREMEDIOUS increase in sales when i did so. The honor system is a great idea and I would love to do it, I think people that cant afford my software should be able to use it just the same, but there are a lot of people who dont have a legitmate reason to purchase it.
Serial Numbers - AnotherJake - Mar 27, 2005 10:03 PM
Encoding credit card information into a serial number is a bad idea. The number belongs to the credit card company, not the consumer as people seem to presume. You're jacking with the credit card company's security system for use in your own. It could bring on massive litigation if things went bad and exposed their customers to fraud.
Serial Numbers - kodex - Mar 28, 2005 10:16 AM
I dont see it as anymore wrong then using your credit card number as a order tracking/identifcation number, which more and more companies are doing. If it is ok with the credit card companies to use your credit card number unchanged as an ID number, why would they complain if you used it modified as a serial number?
Serial Numbers - sealfin - Mar 28, 2005 10:52 AM
@maaaaark: unfortunately I've lost the link to the article, but there's evidence that feature-limited shareware performs considerably better than unlimited use shareware (although the article only considered productivity shareware, not games); here's yet-another-Steve-Pavlina-article on piracy which seems to have the opposite message though â€“ namely, that pirates would never register anyway, no matter the incentive to or the anti-piracy measures taken...
Serial Numbers - AnotherJake - Mar 28, 2005 10:57 AM
kodex Wrote:I dont see it as anymore wrong then using your credit card number as a order tracking/identifcation number, which more and more companies are doing.I've never heard of that. Do you have an example?
Serial Numbers - DanLab - Mar 28, 2005 11:29 AM
i cant tell you how but i converted 15 pirates to buy my game (should be more)
note: talking about a single game, it was a succeful test on some protection
you pirate becoz you can, if you cant pirate a game there is a chance you go to buy it (if you like it of course).
Please stop thinking about : piracy dont make you loose sales, its totally wrong
now to go back to the subject, the idea of serial with expiration date should be ok, but its always easy to hack.
Serial Numbers - FCCovett - Mar 28, 2005 11:31 AM
Most users are just unconcerned with a serial number being generated from their credit card number. I still think the best way to deal with this situation is to put out a limited demo and then allow only legitimate users to have access to the full-version. Of course, the full-version itself should be able to activate itself (or not) after contacting the server, to prevent it from being passed forward.