Questions regarding voting?

Moderator
Posts: 623
Joined: 2007.09
Post: #1
So I had a question regarding voting that Carlos said to post here. As you should know, the public voting link is at http://www.udevgames.com/vote/.

Anyway, I emailed Carlos, asking him if we are suppose to rate our own games. His reply is quoted below:
Quote:No

- Lincoln Green
http://www.binkworks.com/
DoG
Moderator
Posts: 869
Joined: 2003.01
Post: #2
I... err... LOL?

It's a public vote, free for all. The rules say "Entries will be scored by the public (including entrants) for “Best Overall Game.”" For what the rules are worth these days, that is. So, go rate your own game.

There's no way to enforce a rule against that, anyway, so it would be pointless to enact.
Apprentice
Posts: 17
Joined: 2006.10
Post: #3
And what if you want to pan your own game because you feel you did an inadequate job?
Apprentice
Posts: 10
Joined: 2009.02
Post: #4
When it come to the "Best Overall" anyone can vote for any game.

When it comes to '"Best Gameplay", "Best Graphics", etc., the rules state: "For the six “peer” categories, each entrant will score every entry besides their own."

Also, from past and recent emails, it seems steps have been and will be taken to prevent any shenanigans.
Moderator
Posts: 623
Joined: 2007.09
Post: #5
Hey, don't shoot or in any other way harm the messenger!
Anyway, you'll have to talk to Carlos about that. The rule could cause problems if people have already started voting for their own games.

- Lincoln Green
http://www.binkworks.com/
DoG
Moderator
Posts: 869
Joined: 2003.01
Post: #6
DavidGuy Wrote:When it comes to '"Best Gameplay", "Best Graphics", etc., the rules state: "For the six “peer” categories, each entrant will score every entry besides their own."

Also, from past and recent emails, it seems steps have been and will be taken to prevent any shenanigans.

Yes, everyone has been looked at sharply and been warned to behave like good chaps.

There's 20 entries if I counted right, but I am taking bets how many votes we'll see, should the voting data ever be made public, considering there isn't even a way to track who has actually cast a vote, and no way to revise your vote, either. So even if noone maliciously tries to influence voting, there's about 101 things that can and will go wrong, and will distort scoring.
Moderator
Posts: 623
Joined: 2007.09
Post: #7
DoG Wrote:Yes, everyone has been looked at sharply and been warned to behave like good chaps.

There's 20 entries if I counted right, but I am taking bets how many votes we'll see, should the voting data ever be made public, considering there isn't even a way to track who has actually cast a vote, and no way to revise your vote, either. So even if noone maliciously tries to influence voting, there's about 101 things that can and will go wrong, and will distort scoring.

Umm, I thought Carlos had some kind of IP flag going?

What do you mean?

- Lincoln Green
http://www.binkworks.com/
Moderator
Posts: 682
Joined: 2002.11
Post: #8
I know I go through a half dozen IPs in any given day. I just burned through three just by disconnecting from wired internet, turning wireless on, and connecting to VPN.

My web site - Games, music, Python stuff
DoG
Moderator
Posts: 869
Joined: 2003.01
Post: #9
Hairball183 Wrote:Umm, I thought Carlos had some kind of IP flag going?

What do you mean?

The IP flag *is* Carlos.
Moderator
Posts: 623
Joined: 2007.09
Post: #10
So... What's happening then?
I'm not going to vote for my game because Carlos said not to and in the event that he does have some kind of system that flags IPs, I don't want to be excluded.
On the other hand, will that put those of us who don't vote for ourselves in a crippled position(i.e is my game good enough to survive without 10 points)

I'll let someone else figure it out. Smile

- Lincoln Green
http://www.binkworks.com/
Member
Posts: 44
Joined: 2008.12
Post: #11
I had assumed voting would be made public after the contest. I took a peek at one of the voting pages (even though I'm not ready to cast my votes yet), and noticed there is a review section. I had planned to add at least a few sentences to each of my votes explaining how I voted and what I like and don't like about each game. If the developer doesn't get to see that info I won't bother.
Personally I would like to get that kind of feedback from every developer in the contest. I've gotten some good constructive feedback about my game, but would always like more. Thats part of the point of the contest in my mind. Helps us make better games.
Member
Posts: 338
Joined: 2004.07
Post: #12
mattness Wrote:I had assumed voting would be made public after the contest. I took a peek at one of the voting pages (even though I'm not ready to cast my votes yet), and noticed there is a review section. I had planned to add at least a few sentences to each of my votes explaining how I voted and what I like and don't like about each game. If the developer doesn't get to see that info I won't bother.
Personally I would like to get that kind of feedback from every developer in the contest. I've gotten some good constructive feedback about my game, but would always like more. Thats part of the point of the contest in my mind. Helps us make better games.

Well in 2004 we did get those comments, so I wouldn't worry about it. Granted we got them after the voting was over and the results were tallied but that was fine by me. Getting comments beforehand is what the feedback threads were for.

I also intend to give everyone an in-depth review, at least a paragraph for each game with plusses and minuses. I remember Aaron Sullivan did that in 2004 and it was very much appreciated.

Justin Ficarrotta
http://www.justinfic.com
"It is better to be The Man than to work for The Man." - Alexander Seropian
Moderator
Posts: 623
Joined: 2007.09
Post: #13
mattness Wrote:I had assumed voting would be made public after the contest. I took a peek at one of the voting pages (even though I'm not ready to cast my votes yet), and noticed there is a review section. I had planned to add at least a few sentences to each of my votes explaining how I voted and what I like and don't like about each game. If the developer doesn't get to see that info I won't bother.
Personally I would like to get that kind of feedback from every developer in the contest. I've gotten some good constructive feedback about my game, but would always like more. Thats part of the point of the contest in my mind. Helps us make better games.

I'd planned on doing that, but I've only scored one game so far, and, frankly, I couldn't think of any criticism that I hadn't posted already(And I didn't post much).
But yeah, that's a good idea.

- Lincoln Green
http://www.binkworks.com/
Member
Posts: 37
Joined: 2009.02
Post: #14
DoG Wrote:I... err... LOL?

It's a public vote, free for all. The rules say "Entries will be scored by the public (including entrants) for “Best Overall Game.”" For what the rules are worth these days, that is. So, go rate your own game.

There's no way to enforce a rule against that, anyway, so it would be pointless to enact.

I think the rules could be written a lot more clearly on this point, but having seen that on the peer voting pages there is an overall score category it seems the:

"Entries will be scored by the public (including entrants) for “Best Overall Game.” Entries will be scored by entrants only, in six additional categories:"

Is all referring to the pages we are supposed to use to peer vote, not to the public vote. At least that's my take on it.
DoG
Moderator
Posts: 869
Joined: 2003.01
Post: #15
pinguoren Wrote:I think the rules could be written a lot more clearly on this point, but having seen that on the peer voting pages there is an overall score category [...]

The rules are pretty clear, as far as I am concerned, the only problem is that the voting pages do not conform to the rules.
Thread Closed 

Possibly Related Threads...
Thread: Author Replies: Views: Last Post
  uDG08 Voting Results and Methods AnotherJake 111 48,502 Mar 20, 2009 05:15 PM
Last Post: pinguoren
  uDG voting DoG 11 5,925 Mar 7, 2009 09:57 AM
Last Post: FlamingHairball
  How will public voting work? pinguoren 7 5,220 Mar 2, 2009 11:22 AM
Last Post: Carlos Camacho
  Networking Minicontest "Voting" aarku 26 11,233 May 9, 2008 08:36 PM
Last Post: PowerMacX
  Webcomic Contest - Voting DoG 11 7,401 Jun 18, 2007 01:58 AM
Last Post: DoG