Get Z vector of rotation matrix?
I had created a quaternion of rotations which I then create a matrix from using the following code:
(ThemsAllTook may recognise this code , thanks for your useful resources)
But when I try to get the z vector (like the quaternion is an aeroplane and the z vector is forward) straaaange things happen.
Here's the code:
Why is this not working? Most of the functions are from ThemsAllTooks handy tutorials but I can post them if you like.
NeHe's way involves only two axes (axis?).
Thanks in advance
mikey
P.S. I did post on OpenGL forums but with some not very helpful replies so you'll probably find them.
Code:
matrix quatToMatrix(quaternion quat) {
matrix qmatrix;
qmatrix.m[0] = (1.0f  (2.0f * ((quat.y * quat.y) + (quat.z * quat.z))));
qmatrix.m[1] = (2.0f * ((quat.x * quat.y) + (quat.z * quat.w)));
qmatrix.m[2] = (2.0f * ((quat.x * quat.z)  (quat.y * quat.w)));
qmatrix.m[3] = 0.0f;
qmatrix.m[4] = (2.0f * ((quat.x * quat.y)  (quat.z * quat.w)));
qmatrix.m[5] = (1.0f  (2.0f * ((quat.x * quat.x) + (quat.z * quat.z))));
qmatrix.m[6] = (2.0f * ((quat.y * quat.z) + (quat.x * quat.w)));
qmatrix.m[7] = 0.0f;
qmatrix.m[8] = (2.0f * ((quat.x * quat.z) + (quat.y * quat.w)));
qmatrix.m[9] = (2.0f * ((quat.y * quat.z)  (quat.x * quat.w)));
qmatrix.m[10] = (1.0f  (2.0f * ((quat.x * quat.x) + (quat.y * quat.y))));
qmatrix.m[11] = 0.0f;
qmatrix.m[12] = 0.0f;
qmatrix.m[13] = 0.0f;
qmatrix.m[14] = 0.0f;
qmatrix.m[15] = 1.0f;
return qmatrix;
}
(ThemsAllTook may recognise this code , thanks for your useful resources)
But when I try to get the z vector (like the quaternion is an aeroplane and the z vector is forward) straaaange things happen.
Here's the code:
Code:
shipRotation.z = pitch * DEG_TO_RAD ; // converts the pitch to radians
shipRotation.y = heading * DEG_TO_RAD ; // likewise
shipRotation.x = roll * DEG_TO_RAD; // and roll
q1 = eulerToQuat(shipRotation); // makes q1
q2 = quatMult(q1,q2); // multiplies with the existing quaternion
shipMatrix = quatToMatrix(q2); // creates matrix
glMultMatrixf( shipMatrix.m ); // multiplies matrix (was made identity at start of frame)
translation.x = shipMatrix.m[8]; // look at the matrix struct for this
translation.y = shipMatrix.m[9]; // ''
translation.z = shipMatrix.m[10];// ''
translation = vectorByScalar(translation, airspeed); // multiplies vector by scalar
xp = translation.x;
yp = translation.y;
zp = translation.z;
glTranslatef(xp ,yp,zp);
Why is this not working? Most of the functions are from ThemsAllTooks handy tutorials but I can post them if you like.
NeHe's way involves only two axes (axis?).
Thanks in advance
mikey
P.S. I did post on OpenGL forums but with some not very helpful replies so you'll probably find them.
~ Bring a Pen ~
Pulling a front vector straight out of the matrix probably isn't what you want to do. I'd set up a vector to point at whatever is your forward direction in the identity orientation, then multiply it by your matrix to get the desired result. Something like this:
Glad you found my code useful!
Code:
Vector3 vector = {0.0f, 0.0f, 1.0f};
vector = Matrix_multiplyVector3(matrix, vector);
// vector now contains a forward vector for your current orientation (may need to be normalized if your matrix shears or scales)
Glad you found my code useful!
Though that is equivalent to extracting the 3rd column. Are your matrices stored row or column major? You might be extracting the row instead of the column.
Still, for readability's sake I'd take ThemsAllTook's suggestion. It might be 0.1% slower, but it's less lines of code to write, understand, and potentially screw up.
Still, for readability's sake I'd take ThemsAllTook's suggestion. It might be 0.1% slower, but it's less lines of code to write, understand, and potentially screw up.
Scott Lembcke  Howling Moon Software
Author of Chipmunk Physics  A fast and simple rigid body physics library in C.
Hmm. I change my code to:
But the screen jitters around in a circle along the z plane?
Code:
glMultMatrixf( shipMatrix.m );
// glGetFloatv(GL_MODELVIEW_MATRIX, shipMatrix.m);
shipFinalRotation = matrixByVector(shipMatrix , shipFinalRotation);
translation = vectorByScalar(shipFinalRotation, airspeed);
xp += translation.x;
yp += translation.y;
zp += translation.z;
glTranslatef(xp ,yp,zp);
/*
But the screen jitters around in a circle along the z plane?
~ Bring a Pen ~
Skorche Wrote:Though that is equivalent to extracting the 3rd column.
Now that I think about it again, you're right. When I wrote that post, I'd somehow reached a different conclusion. Must've been tired.
Only applicable if {0, 0, 1} is your identity forward vector, though.
So why does nothing happen when I change my code to:
?
Code:
translation.x = shipMatrix.m[20];
translation.y = shipMatrix.m[21];
translation.z = shipMatrix.m[22];
translation = vectorByScalar(translation, airspeed);
xp += translation.x;
yp += translation.y;
zp += translation.z;
glTranslatef(xp ,yp,zp);
~ Bring a Pen ~
20, 21, 22? How large is this matrix? Those are well outside the bounds of 4x4.
Oh sorry I meant to type 12,13 and 14. But the result is still the same .
~ Bring a Pen ~
mikey Wrote:There are 0100 kinds of people in the world: those who understand binary, those who don't , and those who can't count.
4 kinds of people? 64? Sorry for being OT, but this is just puzzling
You answered this question yourself by counting the binary and counting decimals. Therefore you can count and create the fourth catergory.
~ Bring a Pen ~
Anyway, I meant to type 8,9 and 10. On further inspection these produce an odd orbiting motion. Sorry to seem stupid but I really can't see why this isn't working.
~ Bring a Pen ~
Anyone? .........
~ Bring a Pen ~
It's difficult for us to troubleshoot without more information. Maybe if you post a video or some screenshots?
OK, here's a video:
http://tinypic.com/player.php?v=2e6c5ew&s=6
You probably want to keep track of the readouts at the top left.
http://tinypic.com/player.php?v=2e6c5ew&s=6
You probably want to keep track of the readouts at the top left.
~ Bring a Pen ~
So, the way the ship jitters is the problem? It's pretty hard to tell what's going on in a wholesystem test like this. If I were trying to debug this, I'd pull out the relevant code into an assmallaspossible test app so that I could inspect and experiment with the problematic behavior in isolation. Once you solve the problem there, you should be able to bring it back into your main application and have everything work better.
Possibly Related Threads...
Thread:  Author  Replies:  Views:  Last Post  
Strange problem while using 4x4 Rotation Matrix  Man With No Name  6  4,520 
Mar 11, 2008 08:00 AM Last Post: Man With No Name 

Rotation along directional vector  evenmybird  3  3,104 
Aug 25, 2006 10:01 PM Last Post: Hasty 

Using a matrix to generate a new vector position  imikedaman  6  5,334 
Jul 16, 2006 01:17 PM Last Post: imikedaman 

Simple 2D Matrix Rotation isn't working  Joseph Duchesne  2  3,180 
Jun 19, 2005 08:41 AM Last Post: Joseph Duchesne 